DND NEXT!! Thursday, Jan 19 2012 

5th edition is coming out and that makes everyone excited and nervous.  People tossing ideas like they think it’s going to impact what WOTC has.  I think it’s great to come up with all these ideas and maybe this will spawn some people to get together and make a new version or put in house rules to try out in their current game.  However, I do not think we will be getting to affect the foundation as much as everyone would like to hope.  I doubt we are going to create completely new mechanics like “bennies” or a spell point system.

This will be pretty much like what we had Warmachine/Hordes field test and the Pathfinder beta.  Hopefully without having to pay to do the beta like they did with Pathfinder?  And less whining from Warmachine people on the hordes play test.   As we saw in those we had the foundation and a lot of items already built we just needed to tweak items to get them just right.

WHAT DO WE KNOW?   What we know is that they have some kind of outline and enough for a sneak peak to be shown at DDXP.  And we may or may not get something out of that to let us know what to expect.  There is a friends and family beta test going in right now.  Several bloggers are in on it and maybe after a certain period of time they will be allowed to say their impressions.  We also know that there will be an OPEN test supposedly in the spring time.  That will give us our first look at what’s in store for us in DNDNEXT!

Wow let me say there are a ton of ideas and people out there with what they want to see.  And it is seriously mind-blowing to see so many people involved and that’s those who are in specific groups and not those who dodge forums.  So I can imagine all the feedback WOTC will get when this goes OPEN.  I do not envy them that task.

Things I want people to think about are this.  If you are playing any version of D&D or Pathfinder you are doing it right!  We all enjoy playing games and if your group is having fun with it then that’s that.  So to tell me my idea is dumb because I like a particular mechanic then you are not what we need in a play test.  Please do not waste WOTC’s time go back to your cave and play your game and let the rest of us try to make this the best edition for what we want. 

 I’ve seen several people go off about battle grids are horrible please do not have them, without giving a why.  Or 4e had no role-playing to it.  Really or is it because your DM sucked?  Yep, I just called out your groups DM, right there.  Role playing is what your group makes of it I am sure everyone has had good and poor experiences NO MATTER THE EDITION.  A poor group can sour anything.  So to blame an entire edition and say it had no role-playing in it makes you sound uninformed.  4E every class played the same?  What really?  So you are telling me that it’s okay for my cleric to get stuck in to monsters and pretend to tank?  Or for other simile that Cygnar plays exactly like Khador.  Once again you are uninformed and should keep your opinion to yourself.  The only way they are similar is that you mechanically roll dice to see if you’re successful but to succeed you will have to drastically do different things.

Another fallacy I hear is 4e combat takes too long without why it takes too long?  You know what combat took too long any WOD combat!  3E and 4e combat takes about the same amount of time of about 60-90 minutes for an average encounter.  Let’s take a look at the why’s combat is taking too long.  Now this will be my conjecture and from what I’ve seen in running my home game, running events, running/playing Encounters for 2 years, and from stories of those I know personally.

  1. People do NOT PAY ATTENTION.  People are too busy doing other things and when their turn comes up they waste time making a decision.  That’s your fault bad player not the game.
  2. People refuse to learn their characters.  Sorry, you’ve been playing the same guy and same abilities for 8 consecutive weeks it does not take 5 minutes to figure out which power to use.
  3. Out of turn actions.  This can disrupt play but usually only causes a hiccup by example 1 players who go “Whoa, I should of attack with X player cut of y”  Game master “Well you should but I called your name and you didn’t respond”  Once again a player not paying attention causes issues for everyone. 
  4. Rules.  Not having a tight rule set can lead to rules arguments.  I’ve had them in EVERY game I’ve played period.  Tight rule set for the DM helps prevent these arguments. 
  5. Options.  Having too many options can paralyze a player with analysis paralysis.  Yep, understand that in early levels as everyone gets use to things.  And also if something just happened that was really crushing and changed everything which is an exception not an every time occurrence.  But then this turns to point 2 LEARN YOUR CHARACTERS ABILITIES after a time.

In my next post I’ll go through some of the things I would like to see in DNDNEXT.

 

Advertisements

User error Thursday, Sep 9 2010 

I think  with technology as it is today everyone has fallen prey to this. everything to remotes not working because dead batteries to screen savers not coming on because you turn your monitor off before they come on in power settings. We see this in gaming as well. Some of it just happens and some of it is blatant.

The idea is to always play perfectly and make no mistakes. If you can go back and say I made all the correct decisions with the information I had then you can not fault yourself for losing. Playing perfectly means you doing all the right things even those that hinder you when you play. For instance remembering to take damage when you cut for fury, tap a painland, retrieve an encounter power via a feat. No one is perfect and errors will occur but with two or more people there to police inadvertent actions can be caught.

I’ve seen the rising of “simple mistakes” in competitive play recently. Now I do not know if it’s the rise of new players or people trying to play the system. I have seen cases of both recently. The best defense for this is not to allow any take backs in competitive play, no exceptions. I watched a player try this ploy in a tournament recently. They “forgot” to place focus during convenient times. After watching this happen in two different rounds I got wise to the situation. In my game my opponent did not allocate focus on the third turn after being perfect for two turns. I said no after he started moving his second jack to allowing him to add focus. Lots of whining from my opponent about how unfair it was and it ruined his game.  The easy answer is do not ask or give takebacks.

Footbal season is starting today and I’m sure makes lots of guys happy and wives miserable.  I’m just glad its back!

Hardcore Controversy Sunday, Aug 8 2010 

We all hear the scuttlebutt on Lord Tyrant Watts getting the fastest caster kill during hard core.  Then we hear about him getting DQ’d and losing the title as well as being barred from playing the championship rounds.  The only facts I know of for sure is he was DQ’d during hard core and this what Watts had to say in his own words.

Can be found here http://privateerpressforums.com/showthread.php?32176-Hardcore-news. post 42 (kind of ironic)

Here is what happened. I had used makeda, popped my feat and was getting ready to charge with Karn. I moved her up and said I heal Karn for 1. As I said that a judge interupted me and said that he wanted to make sure I measured correctly because he thought it would be close. So he distracted me here. I go to move Karn and the judge asks for the tape and moves Karn in a manner that he thought to be correct. Karn then charges kills some things and fate walks to ELich. ELich player then moves, pops feat, and asks how much life is on Karn? I show him the card and he says that Karn doesn’t have any spirit. I look down and guess what? When I was distracted by the judge, I only declaired that I was healing and didn’t pull the fury away. I told my opponent I would remove the fury, but the judge DQed me and accused me of cheating.

In the end it really sucks, but unfortunatly it was all a huge misunderstaning in a high pressure situation.

Ahh, well.

Now I think we need to wait and find out what the official Privateer word is on this before jumping to conclusions.  I found this similar to the David Williams cheating situation back in circa 2002-3? where at Pro Tour event he was accused of marking his deck.  Everyone jumped to defend Mr. Williams because they did not want to believe their hero did anything wrong.  Personally having played with the man back before he was big time and having had him to my house for practice sessions I was on his side.  I think what we do now is wait for the facts.  I think we all are waiting baited breath to find out PP’s side and that judge.  The other thing I wonder is if after this will Watts end up selling his stuff and leave the scene, even if it was an honest mistake.  How many people are going to be looking at his game even tighter now? 

BIG PROPS to the Focus and Fury for bringing their A game to Gen Con. I am waiting to see if they held their own and won their own 5 Horseman tournament.

Quick Hits Friday, Aug 6 2010 

So I am doing some closet cleaning and this is the stuff I think I can finally part with.

Legend:
NIB – New in box
BM- bare metal and put together

Legion

Shredder blister x2 NIB
Teraph NIB
Carniveran NIB

Skorne
Full Unit of Venators NIB
Base Unit of Accurai NIB
Titan Cannoneer NIB
basilisk drake NIB
venator catapult NIB
ancestral guardian NIB
basilisk krea NIB
cataphract cetrati X5 primed based on cork and pinned

Mercs
lord rockbottom NIB
Gorman BM
Hawk BM

Cygnar (base coats are on all models unless noted)
Kraye BM
Ironclad
2 lancers
centurion
gun mage captain adapt
hunter
sentinel
enemo
estryker
Maxwell Finn BM
Squire BM

Circle (BM)
tharn ravager
blackclad wayfarer x2
tharn bloodtracker x10

Complete Armies (selling these whole not breaking apart)

Legion $500 retail ~$950(1 of each war beast, warlock, and solos, full released units plus UA’s, except scather and pot, Up through Metamorphous)

Skorne $500 retail ~$1050 (1 of each war beast, warlock, full units released units and UA’s, and solos, only min unit of immortals though, Up through Metamorphous)

Trolls $400 retail ~$700
Borka
Grissle
Grim Angus
Epic Madrak

Dire Troll Mauler
Earthbound Dire Troll
Winter troll
Slag troll
Impaler
Axer
Pyre Troll

2 x units of champions
full unit of pygmy long gunners
full unit of kriel warriors
UA for kriel warriors
1 WA for kriel warriors
Full unit of Kriel stone bearers

1 Fell caller
1 unit of swamp gobbers

Cryx $600 retail ~$950
Denegrha
Skarre
Coven
mortenbra
egoreshade

skarlock
slaughterborne
machine wraith
tarterus
rengrave
darragh wrathe
warwitch siren
pistol wraith

full satyxis + UA
min mechanithralls
necro surgeon
full revenant crew
min unit of ghost pirates
min unit of cav
full unit of bane knights
full unit bile thralls
Overlords
5 scrap thralls
2 necrotechs

cankerworm
deathjack
harrower
slayer
seether
2 x deathripper
hell diver
2 x stalker
2 defilers

Privateer Press Books and Magazines

NQ 12-28 Make an offer

Warmachine Pirates book
Warmachine MK II book
Warmachine Retribution book
Warmachine Legends
Hordes Primal
Hordes Evolution
Hordes Metamorphosis

GW
Minotaur painted by Matt Dipietro with 2 handed weapon $30
Minotaur Painted by Matt Dipietro with 2 hand weapons $30

OOP Pirate Ogres $3 a piece or all for $25 ~12
4 regular ogres OOP
1 painted Heroquest OGRE

Warhammer fantasy

GT armies both placed or won the event. Both have won various RT’s as well.
Each comes with a GW case ~50

Khorne Demons $400 painted (40 blood letters demons, 10 flesh hounds, 8 juggernauts, a converted chariot)
CHaos Warriors $300 (2 units of 5 knights of chaos, 2 units of 5 chaos hounds, 8 harpies, 2 unis of 5 maurader horseman with flails, 1 archaeon on foot all painted)

Other Armies

Tomb King Army all painted unless otherwise noted
1 casket of souls
1 skull catapult (new)
2 lich priests on horseback
1 lich king in chariot
1 lich prince w/ two handed weapon in chariot

2 units of 3 chariots full command
2 units of 10 horseman with spears and shields full command

2 units of 5 carrion
1 tomb scorpion
1 bone giant

2 unit boxes of Tomb guard NIB
1 box of khemris skeletons NIB

3 swarms of scorpions

Orc and Goblin Army
Several characters on boars
Mage from chain mail game painted
Orc wizard from Avatars of War
Orc on wyvern painted

1 unit of black orcs (mixed 4th and 6th edition) 20
1 unit of 30 sword and board orcs
1 unit of 30 two hand weapon orcs
1 unit ~20 sword and board orcs
2 units of 10 orcs with boys

1 unit of goblins with HW and shield 30
6 fanatics
10 boar boys
10 wolf riders
6 squig hoppers

1 giant

2 pump wagons
4 trolls
2 goblin doom divers
1 ork catapult
2 spear chucka

NIB Fantasy

Beasts of Chaos

beastman regiment NIB
chaos ogres nib
maurader horsemen 6ed NIB
dragon ogre shaggoth NIB
3 chaos trolls
1 LE beasts of chaos standard bearer RARE
1 beasts of chaos wizard

warriors of chaos
mauraders on foot box on sprue
limited edition chaos sorcerer X2 NIB
raiders 1st ed x3 NIB
LE archaeon on foot NIB

daemons of chaos
fleshhound of khore x7 NIB
Scylla NIB
steed of slannesh NIB
6 painted nurgle demons
liche king chariot 5th ed
4 dragon ogres bare metal
chaos champions of tzeentch with familiar and birdhead
belakor NIB
Juggernaught of Khorne NIB

bretionnian sorceress on foot and on horseback
Limited edition bretonnian on horseback with spartan helmet

1 rhinos 3rd ed
1 space marine bike sprue

OOP LICH KING CHARIOT

MISC
2painted arbites with bolters and shields $15
1 painted necromunda bounty hunter $10

Chaos
Champion on Disc 2ed NIB
daemon prince NIB
juggernaught of khorne NIB
azazel daemon prince NIB

Space marine
marine terminator librrarian 2ed NIB
space marine with las cannon 2ed ed NIB
dark angels 3 ed le sgt $20

eldar warp spiders NIB
eldar howling banshee exarch

LOTS OF 40k Space Marine and Chaos Marine items

Non GW OR PP

VOR
growler razorback onehorn pose 2
Razorfang
zykhee stalker 1
vor prototypes
zykhee ranged warrior 1
growler razorback pups x2
zykhee close combat warrior 1
zykhee stalker 2
zykhee close combat warrior 3
zykhee close combat warrior 2
Female Union Sniper

Confrontation (take all for $30)
Spasm Warrior x2
troll de guerre
templar griffon
guerriers skorizes

MISC
Clan wars oni
assassin miniature barbarian
wargods khemru with staff
dagdha warrior druid
assassin miniature falconeer
heru hero with pole arm

D&D Miniatures (Chainmail)
ALL NIB / unpainted
Half Orc fighter
Gnoll box set
Elf Box set
Orc shaman x3
2 LE ogre mercenary NIB
Slaughterpit Gnoll Zombie
Human Glaiver and Crossbowman
Centaur trooper
Stonechild
HUman monk chick super heroes pose
Elvin duelist with dual chain
Gnome with crossbow X2
ogre trooper
ghouls x2
dire badger
halfing thief with crossbow x2
hobgoblin fighter
orc berserker
pulverizer
owlbear
goblin scout x2
goblin trooper x2
skeletal orc
hyena x2
gnoll warrior with flail x2
tiefling fighter
hammerer
minotaur cultist
war ape
zombie troglodytes
bugbear trooper
LE drow warrior

RPG/Board Games/Card Games

Necromunda Book $20

Mutants and Mastermind first edition
M&M Freedom City

Silver Age Sentinels

Battletech Compendium 1640
Battletech Technical Readout 3026
Battletech Technical

SHADOWRUN
1st Edition All Modules

Buffy the Vampire Slayer

DUNGEOUNS AND DRAGONS
1st Edition
Monster Manual
Players Handbook

2nd Edition
Players Handbook

D&D 3rd Edition
Players Handbook
Deities and Demigods
Oriental Adventures
Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting
Sword and Fist
Song and Silence
Master of the Wild
Defenders of the Faith
Tome and Blood
Book of Eldritch Might

Talisman $400 2nd edition GW board game from 80’s (all expansions except Dungeon)

DC Heroes RPG books $3 per book or $50 for lot

6 boxes of various magic cards $30 total

Magic cards:
Dual Land $45 a piece
Set of force of will $200
1 Force of will $50

AWARDS/MISC

first set of L5R Card posters $20 won in the first Dallas kotei ~97?

Magic Mirage Banner $30 (only stores and winners of the prelease have these)

Magic Visions Banner $30 (only stores and winners of the prelease have these)

Terrain $250
(about 20 hills, 4-6 linear wall obstacles, 2-3 houses, modular river pieces that are approximately 6” by 6” that goes about 4′ long, in good condition and professionally made, used at local game store)

Privateer Press Coins and Medals $30 a piece
MK I (2 skorne, 1 troll, 1 circle, 1 Mercenary, 1 Cryx, 1 2nd place)
Beast Hunter medallion
MKII (1 of each Cygnar, Khador, Retribution, Mercenary)

Multiple privateer press pins from C2A league $5 (8 different pens and medals)

Privateer Press Winner Cards $5 a piece

Top 8 qualifer pin from magic $20

Warhammer 25th Anniversary pin $10

Poker table toper $30

Star Wars Phantom Menace limited edition prints still in wrapped box $300 retail $500

Sold:
Retribution army
MISC Skorne
Coins (Skorne, Legion, Cygnar, Khador)
Marvel Super Heroes RPG
Wood Elves army
Salamander armies
Tyranid army
kazay assassins
Misc D&D books

PMorghoul Tier list Tuesday, Jul 6 2010 

What are everyone’s thoughts on this?  I’m not completly sold but will have to look at it more in depth.

Two units of accurai are just odd to me.  From what I understand the accurai unit did not go down in base price or gain any buffs from the cards.  I do not think this is a fluff list eitheir.   Maybe there is an Accurai UA for 1 that makes them worth while or something.  If it only force one unit of accurai that would make worth swallowing.  Lets hold out hope for some better tiers for the other casters.

How to be better player part two Saturday, Jun 12 2010 

Or as I call it learn to accept responsibility for losing and learn from it.
Also one should check out Iron Agenda podcast 81 as well.

So you have read the basic rules and know them fairly well. You know your armies rules and learning the riles of your various opponents. Now time to learn the scenarios and learn from opponents.

Before entering any tournament or even playing a friendly game with a scenarios you need to understand the scenario. Always read it and if you have questions ask about them. If you do not understand and you lose I guarantee your going to feel cheated. Even though the ONLY person at fault was you.

I saw or heard of two different types of examples this weekend. In my first game against a Menoth player he thought you could only score on your own turns. So was upset when I won the game on his turn because he could did not move anyone to contest the point.

The second example was two players both misread the scenario. After turning in the results the judge and a player were talking and the judge found out what happened and turned the result into a draw. I think this is poor decision on the judge part as no one gained an advantage in the match. Both played under the same rules and the original result should have stood. Unless you can catch the error when it happens or there are shenanigans a judge should not make any sort of decision.

Now what should of happened in each of these circumstances was the players should of asked for clarification.  They should of made sure of what was going with their opponents ahead of time during the tournament.  This could of taken place durng set up or the reading of the scenairo.  It does not hurt anyone if you ask questions that you do not understand something.  Because if you get beat because you thought fleeing units counted as contesting and they do not.  Make sure about things and do not assume anything!  Check these out with your opponent and the judge so everyone is on the same page.

I guarentee that my Menoth opponent will remember that you can score points on the end of everyones turn next tournament!

Flowing thoughts Tuesday, Jun 8 2010 

Well tomorrow we have the release of the Cryx book and in a month the release of the mercenary book for Warmachine.  I am very excited to see what is in store for the Merc book.  I can hope for an epic Ashlynn and good storyline.  Then Gen Con will see the release of the Hordes Primal book.

The Ravagore for legion just went up.  It looks like an overblown stinger.  I just feel like Legion beasts are just unispired.  This is the faction lead by the most creative, smartest, and egotistical dragon.  Something just does not feel right these models.  I am getting the feeling that when they swapped the play style of Legion they got confused on what they want to do.  Skorne and legion feel like incomplete factions while Trolls and Circle seem to be aokay. 

The D&D game is going great so far.  They are about to reach the second floor of the Shadow Keep.    All the old school players have picked up fourth edition nicely.  The two newbies to our group are picking it up slowly.  Not sure what I can do to help them catch on faster.  We each help them with the powers and so forth.  But they do take a little extra time trying to figure out what to do.  Those who wish to follow along can check it out here.

I’m back and Fiona Tier List Thursday, Jun 3 2010 

I’m back from work and no AC in my house which is a very bad thing.  Hopefully, I will get back into regular posting again.

Lets take a look at the Fiona tier list.  Unfortunately I think this is just a horrible list.  I do not see any reason to take this instead of just a Highborne list.  This list only gives her 3 units to play with and 2 solos.  Unless of course there are rules in the mercenary book which adds in Thamarite units and solos.  Even then with all these restrictions I would rather play the more well rounded Highborn list with her.  I would think she would of had some access to pirate solos.  This reminds of old magic cards that the company put into sets called idiot tests.  If you played it you were a bad player considering there are way better choices.

Personally, I am looking foward to the Mercenary book to see what there is to it.  I’m looking foward to see what we get for Ashlynn.  Hopefully the Bart and rest of the lists are actually worth playing.

UPDATE:

Sometimes I forget that I need to write not just about how competitive items are but also how they fit into the IK world.  This list fits perfectly for Fiona.  I would think she might of had one or two pirates as she had a ship along with Bart and Shae.   Hopefully we will see some clarification of some Thamarites.

Quick Thoughts on WM Sunday, May 23 2010 

First off, if you have not taken the 60 seconds to enter in their online store contest I suggest you do so. You may find it here.

Second, I am not sure why the new Exemplar Errant solo for menoth is only two points. They took an ability away from Cryx on Rengrave stating that self sacrifice was too good. They gave him an ability that is not as he originally had and thats fine. Now we see it reappear in a different faction? Really, this is a bit irritating and I’m not really a Cryx player. If your going to pull an ability from an original model and state is too good I really do not want to see it again in a different faction. Come on we know you want to move Errants but a bit overkill. Just give Rengrave this ability and everyone will be fine.

Some rumors have been spied around the forums. Now, this is what I call knee jerk reactions since we have to wait to see the real rules for these guys.

Shae Coco Butter Tier List

No character warjacks (are there any in Mercs or is this a hint for things to come?)
Sea Dog Units
Lady Aiyana and Master Holt
Solos – Privateer

Lvl 1: all solos -1pt (really the whole Talion crew at -1 point?)
Lvl 2: Mr Walls = all models/units have easier time getting through forests and rough terrain first turn.
Lvl 3: commodore cannon = better chance of winning starting roll. (+1)
Lvl 4: min 3 jacks battlegroup = battle group moves faster first turn. (+2)

So a tier 3 list should be easily obtained. And hey you get 7 great solos for 7 points. Woo hoo solo machine for Pirates. I mean tier 3 is 25 points with A&H and a full unit of seadogs. 16 points to spend on jacks and go to town. Not completly sure how I feel about this but will ned to see it played in capable hands to decide.

Hordes Turn

QUOTE (Sentry)
The titan sentry
PC gladiator + 1
Gladiaor stats.  One lower def and mat
Spear is p+s = gladiator fists but it has reach
shield p+s 13
tusk I think 15
Brace for impact
hard headanimus
cant really remember. It was silly good though. Something like “models starting in this model’s melee range can only move directly towards it.” Good. Really good.


To borrow a term from Focus and Fury this titan sentry is the epitome of Skornagy. Just because it has a shield and spear it loses a point of mat and defense? Its more points than a gladiator? For a faction that is based on being a cohesive regimented military machine its pretty much looking like a bunch of lameness.

QUOTE (Bomber)
PC 10Blitzer stats, fury 4, mat, rat 5. Blitzer stats

Snacking and regen are the only special rules.

2 p+s 15 fists (blitzer stats)

RANGE 8, POW 16, AOE 4, RoF 2 ranged attack.

Animus that grants a model immune to blast damage.

Finally, donkey kong of the Trolls.  Yep, he and the impaler hang out a lot.  Rof 2 pow 16 aoe 4 is so horrible for 10 points.  He may not be an all star but this guy is solid.

Warpwolf Stalker of Awesome Wednesday, May 19 2010 

The stats were given in today’s newsletter you may find the stats here

This thing looks exceptional. From his reach weapon of 16, his animus SPRINT (which can be doled out to any model), to his warpings (strength, stealth, beserk). He is a little pricey at 10 points but he is a toolbox of greatness. Warp this guy for beserk charge him at a threat of 11” then have him sprint another six to engange some other guys. Its the Lord of the Feast in beast form. Sprint gives even more movement shennigans to the skirmishing faction known as circle. This model makes me drool with how good it is.

Defense 14 also helps put it near a hard to hit for most basic infantry and most likely boosts by beast/jacks to hit. Well except those cygnar jacks with their Mat 7/8. He is a non-wold with pathfinder which means he can do his thing on his own without getting help. A very solid model for the already solid faction of Circle with all its incredible choices. I am guessing we will be seeing an all Wolf theme list and this guy is a definite place for that. I think he makes a great compliment to the other Warpwolves but is not a directly replacement.

Next Page »